This article examines the reconfiguration of the Italian Court of Auditors considering the 2026 reform, focusing on the constitutional and systemic implications of changes to its organisational structure, career framework and functional balance. Starting from the traditional model grounded in the unity of jurisdictional function and the internal independence of accounting magistrates, the paper reconstructs the evolution of the Court’s institutional role under Law no. 20/1994 and critically assesses the transformative impact of the recent legislative intervention. The 2026 reform is analysed not merely as a technical adjustment of administrative liability, but as a structural redefinition of the relationship between jurisdiction, control, and advisory functions. Attention is devoted to the risks associated with the progressive integration of functions, the centralisation and verticalisation of prosecutorial powers, and the potential emergence of a de facto separation of careers. These developments are evaluated against constitutional principles, especially judicial independence (Art. 107 Const.), separation of powers and the requirement of impartiality. The article further explores the rearticulation of administrative liability, including the restrictive redefinition of “gross negligence”, the introduction of quantitative caps on damages, and the enhanced role of advisory opinions with exculpatory effects. These elements contribute to a shift from an ex-post accountability model to a preventive and legitimising framework, with significant consequences for the effectiveness of financial oversight. The paper argues that the reform risks transforming the Court of Auditors from a jurisdictional body safeguarding public finances into a consultative actor, embedded within administrative decision-making. Ultimately, the constitutional compatibility of the reform will depend on its implementing measures, particularly whether they preserve the balance between administrative efficiency and public accountability embedded in the Italian constitutional order.

La disciplina delle carriere e delle funzioni della Corte dei conti alla luce della riforma del 2026: profili costituzionali e sistemici

Loredana Giani
2026-01-01

Abstract

This article examines the reconfiguration of the Italian Court of Auditors considering the 2026 reform, focusing on the constitutional and systemic implications of changes to its organisational structure, career framework and functional balance. Starting from the traditional model grounded in the unity of jurisdictional function and the internal independence of accounting magistrates, the paper reconstructs the evolution of the Court’s institutional role under Law no. 20/1994 and critically assesses the transformative impact of the recent legislative intervention. The 2026 reform is analysed not merely as a technical adjustment of administrative liability, but as a structural redefinition of the relationship between jurisdiction, control, and advisory functions. Attention is devoted to the risks associated with the progressive integration of functions, the centralisation and verticalisation of prosecutorial powers, and the potential emergence of a de facto separation of careers. These developments are evaluated against constitutional principles, especially judicial independence (Art. 107 Const.), separation of powers and the requirement of impartiality. The article further explores the rearticulation of administrative liability, including the restrictive redefinition of “gross negligence”, the introduction of quantitative caps on damages, and the enhanced role of advisory opinions with exculpatory effects. These elements contribute to a shift from an ex-post accountability model to a preventive and legitimising framework, with significant consequences for the effectiveness of financial oversight. The paper argues that the reform risks transforming the Court of Auditors from a jurisdictional body safeguarding public finances into a consultative actor, embedded within administrative decision-making. Ultimately, the constitutional compatibility of the reform will depend on its implementing measures, particularly whether they preserve the balance between administrative efficiency and public accountability embedded in the Italian constitutional order.
2026
Court of Auditors, administrative liability, judicial independence, financial oversight, constitutional reform
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
13818-27673-1-PB.pdf

accesso aperto

Licenza: Dominio pubblico
Dimensione 1.09 MB
Formato Adobe PDF
1.09 MB Adobe PDF Visualizza/Apri

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.14092/12063
 Attenzione

Attenzione! I dati visualizzati non sono stati sottoposti a validazione da parte dell'ateneo

Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
social impact