The essay is a comparative analysis on the issue of employees’ participation in the enterprise and its variations with respect to the rights of union involvement. The legal systems being compared are the sort supranational European Union and those of Germany, France, Spain, Italy; the first two Countries are those in which the experience of employees’ participation has a greater tradition, while the second two are those in which the debate on legislation on participation is more relevant and takes place just looking at the German tradition and, in part, to the French one. The Author highlights the inadequacy of the technical regulations, and of the consequent results, of Communitarian law when guided by s.c. “upward harmonization” (particularly towards the German model) and, instead, increased utility of a more recent legislative approach that takes into account founding national specificities (primarily the constitutional principles about systems of representation and collective bargaining) and that seek a common denominator of those in which each national legislature may recognize in pursuing the implementation of a discipline on participation. Flipping through " wires" and " nodes" of participation in the various jurisdictions, emerges from the essay , that the declination of the relationship between the right to collective bargaining and the factual reality , you cannot suffer a priori assumption that it could be better to leave the rule of collective representation only to the balance of power between unions. The choice of themes , tools and , above all, the interlocutors becomes an essential moment in the creation of a discipline on the involvement of workers in the undertaking and should be entrusted to the rationality of the law that represents the true choice to the assumption of responsibility for the acts that this entails.

Employees' participation, involvement and collective bargaining; comparative thoughts in search for a common european denominator

TESTA F
2013-01-01

Abstract

The essay is a comparative analysis on the issue of employees’ participation in the enterprise and its variations with respect to the rights of union involvement. The legal systems being compared are the sort supranational European Union and those of Germany, France, Spain, Italy; the first two Countries are those in which the experience of employees’ participation has a greater tradition, while the second two are those in which the debate on legislation on participation is more relevant and takes place just looking at the German tradition and, in part, to the French one. The Author highlights the inadequacy of the technical regulations, and of the consequent results, of Communitarian law when guided by s.c. “upward harmonization” (particularly towards the German model) and, instead, increased utility of a more recent legislative approach that takes into account founding national specificities (primarily the constitutional principles about systems of representation and collective bargaining) and that seek a common denominator of those in which each national legislature may recognize in pursuing the implementation of a discipline on participation. Flipping through " wires" and " nodes" of participation in the various jurisdictions, emerges from the essay , that the declination of the relationship between the right to collective bargaining and the factual reality , you cannot suffer a priori assumption that it could be better to leave the rule of collective representation only to the balance of power between unions. The choice of themes , tools and , above all, the interlocutors becomes an essential moment in the creation of a discipline on the involvement of workers in the undertaking and should be entrusted to the rationality of the law that represents the true choice to the assumption of responsibility for the acts that this entails.
2013
Employees' participation
collective bargaining
comparative labor law
European trade union law
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
F. Testa_ Employees participation in the enterprise_EJSL_2013_4-E.pdf

non disponibili

Dimensione 208.27 kB
Formato Adobe PDF
208.27 kB Adobe PDF   Visualizza/Apri   Richiedi una copia

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.14092/2342
 Attenzione

Attenzione! I dati visualizzati non sono stati sottoposti a validazione da parte dell'ateneo

Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
social impact